Peer Review Process
Appeals Process
LGJSS is committed to a fair, transparent, and accountable editorial process. Authors who believe that an editorial decision was based on a misunderstanding, factual error, or procedural concern may submit a formal appeal for reconsideration. The appeals process is as follows:
Submission of an Appeal: Authors must submit a written appeal to the Editorial Office within the timeframe specified by the journal, clearly explaining the reasons for the appeal and providing supporting evidence where applicable.
Grounds for Appeal: Appeals should be based on scientific or procedural issues, such as factual inaccuracies, misinterpretation of the manuscript, or concerns regarding the peer-review process. Appeals based solely on disagreement with reviewers' opinions are generally not sufficient.
Editorial Review: The Editor-in-Chief or a designated senior editor will review the appeal, the reviewer reports, editorial correspondence, and any additional supporting information.
Independent Assessment: If necessary, the manuscript may be referred to additional independent reviewers or editorial board members for further evaluation.
Decision is Final: The decision made following the appeal review is final and binding. Multiple appeals concerning the same manuscript will generally not be considered unless significant new evidence is presented.
Professional Communication: Authors are expected to communicate respectfully throughout the appeals process. Abusive, offensive, or inappropriate correspondence may result in the appeal being discontinued.
Final Decision
After careful consideration, the journal will communicate one of the following decisions:
- Uphold the original editorial decision.
- Invite the authors to submit a revised manuscript for further review.
- Reopen the peer-review process.
- Reverse the original decision in exceptional circumstances.
LGJSS handles all appeals confidentially, impartially, and in accordance with internationally recognized publication ethics and best editorial practices, ensuring that every appeal receives a fair and objective assessment.
Submitting an Appeal
